| ID | First name | Last name | School | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1961 | Katelyn | Sheenan | Bryn Mawr | Varsity |
| 1960 | Dylan | Cowit | Johns Hopkins | Varsity |
| 1959 | Prayuth | Naduthota | Brandeis | Varsity |
| 1958 | Erika | Liu | Wellesley | Varsity |
| 1957 | Shubhro | Saha | Princeton | Varsity |
| 1956 | Audrey | Leasure | Johns Hopkins | Varsity |
| 1955 | Jodie | Goodman | Swarthmore | Varsity |
| 1954 | Arjun | Gupta | The College of New Jersey | Varsity |
| 1953 | Alyssa | Adler | Brandeis | Varsity |
| 1952 | Isaac | Dulin | Swarthmore | Varsity |
| 1951 | Juliana | Vigorita | Johns Hopkins | Varsity |
| 1950 | Chris | Riehle | University of Chicago | Varsity |
| 1949 | Seth | Elder | Syracuse | Varsity |
| 1948 | Rumit | Gambhir | Franklin and Marshall | Varsity |
| 1947 | Matthew | Rohn | Franklin and Marshall | Varsity |
| 1946 | Jacob | Emont | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1945 | Matt | Corwin | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1944 | Matt | Sokol | American | Varsity |
| 1943 | Tom | Krizanovic | Odette | Varsity |
| 1942 | Kenny | Dickmeyer | Franklin and Marshall | Varsity |
| 1941 | Celina | Bussiere | Odette | Varsity |
| 1940 | Evan | Blum | American | Varsity |
| 1938 | Michael | Duncan | Duke | Varsity |
| 1937 | Vamsi | Chunduru | Johns Hopkins | Varsity |
| 1936 | Keizra | Mecklai | Duke | Varsity |