| ID | First name | Last name | School | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1934 | Jacob | Emount | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1933 | Justin | Love | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1932 | Alex | Pollock | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1931 | Juliana | Vigorito | Johns Hopkins | Varsity |
| 1930 | Jordan | Roth | Brandeis | Varsity |
| 1929 | Leandro | Leviste | Yale | Varsity |
| 1928 | Reed | Berry | Yale | Varsity |
| 1927 | Michael | Norton | Brandeis | Varsity |
| 1926 | Peter | Falk | Northeastern | Varsity |
| 1925 | Rose | Owen | Wellesley | Varsity |
| 1924 | Zach | Plyam | Yale | Varsity |
| 1923 | Justin | Mackin | Syracuse | Varsity |
| 1922 | Daniel | Peselimer | Bates | Varsity |
| 1921 | Kelly | Wu | Yale | Varsity |
| 1919 | Hoang | Capistran | Syracuse | Varsity |
| 1918 | Sarah | Pizzano | Brandeis | Varsity |
| 1917 | Victoria | Sienczewski | Stanford | Varsity |
| 1916 | Bill | Lewis | George Washington | Varsity |
| 1915 | Lizz | Crivaro | University of Pittsburgh | Varsity |
| 1914 | Thomas | Helgerman | University of Pittsburgh | Varsity |
| 1913 | Max | Barnhart | UMBC | Varsity |
| 1912 | Eric | Warren | West Point | Varsity |
| 1911 | Will | Moore | West Point | Varsity |
| 1910 | Meryem | Uzumcu | Rutgers | Varsity |
| 1909 | Sean | Leonard | Rutgers | Varsity |